Skip to content
Zone Family Path

An ‘Brainless’ Dismissal That ‘Defines’ The English Ashes Series Campaign

In a series for the urn riddled with poor cricket, England’s wicketkeeper Smith somehow plumb new depths.

Smith’s dismissal on the second morning in the final Test versus the Aussies was labelled “among the poorest to witness” according to BBC chief cricket commentator Aggers.

Ex-England fast bowler Steven Finn, commentating on TNT, stated the shot was “totally senseless”.

An Unusual Scenario

As the lunch break neared in Sydney and Australia attempting to burgle a few overs to hurry along the new ball, the hosts turned to the part-timer Labuschagne to bowl some of his extremely rare medium-pace.

Smith had moved to a sketchy 46. His stand alongside Joe Root – unbeaten with a superb century – had added 94.

The Australian side, without a frontline spinner, were using the occasional off-spin from Travis Head at the other end.

“We better describe this setting, as it is unbelievable,” said Agnew via the radio. “He usually bowls wrist-spin but here he is used as a bowler of short balls. There is nobody in catching position near the batter.”

Somehow, Smith obliged. Off the fourth delivery Labuschagne bowled, the England wicketkeeper moved back and attempted a flat-batted swipe.

He succeeded in picking out the fielder Boland, the sole fielder in the front half on the off-side, at cover point.

‘Filthy’ – The Reaction

In doing so, he succumbed to one of the most staggering dismissals for an English batsman in Test cricket, one that perfectly encapsulates the reckless nature of their loss of the Ashes.

“Goodness no!” cried former England quick Agnew. “I have seen a lot of cricket and that is among the very worst I’ve ever witnessed.”

Alex Hartley, a Women’s World Cup winner with England in 2017, added: “That shot was disgusting. Absolutely awful. It is disgusting.”

Finn, an Ashes winner with England during the 2010-11 down under, was more scathing: “That’s completely brainless. I can’t believe what I’ve seen there. That’s going to be an incredibly quiet changing room for Smith to return to.”

A Nervy Innings Comes to an End

This concluded an edgy innings from Surrey’s Smith, who could have been dismissed to Cameron Green on a number of occasions prior to Labuschagne was brought to bowl.

On 22, Smith was caught, only for the video showed Green overstepped. The following delivery, Smith edged between keeper Alex Carey and Beau Webster.

He also top-edged a Green bouncer over the slip cordon on 30 and, on 34, skied a pull shot that just evaded mid-on.

A Collapse Of Form

This most recent debacle in Sydney comes at the end of a hugely disappointing Ashes series for Smith, continuing a bad patch of form which started during the English summer.

Following his a stunning 184 at Edgbaston versus India in July, his batting average was nearly 59. Eight matches since then, it has fallen to 42.

  • He has passed 50 only once on this tour.
  • At Perth, he did not adapt to the big grounds and was bounced out.
  • In the second Test, his debut in day-night cricket, he put down two vital chances behind the stumps.
  • His 60 in the second innings at Adelaide remains his top series score, yet he holed out off Mitchell Starc just when he was offering England a chance of a miraculous victory chase.

Before the fifth Test he was left out of England’s white-ball teams for the upcoming tour of Sri Lanka and the World T20 that follows.

Doubts About The Future

Smith still has the second-best batting average for a wicketkeeper that has kept in a minimum of 20 Test matches for England, yet his collapse in form could leave questions over his place for the home summer.

“Jamie Smith is far from the form he should be,” said ex-skipper Vaughan. “This side have to start to learn and accept. I saw comments suggesting he would likely receive praise for trying to be aggressive.”

“That is the mindset that is being created within this team and that is why they have failed in Australia. There are times to be aggressive but when it is so near the interval and Marnus Labuschagne is bowling short. I cannot accept that. It epitomises this England side.”

BB
About the author

Benjamin Bradford

Eva is a family therapist and writer who helps families strengthen bonds through mindful communication and shared experiences.

Zone Family Path

Type to search articles.